Old Man’s Cave, once known as Dead Man’s Cave, is steeped in legend and mystery, with stories echoing from the late 1870s to the 1880s. The tale revolves around the grim discovery of a man and his loyal dog, found in a secluded cave nestled near Cedar Grove, Ohio. This man, believed to be a solitary trapper, became the focal point of local lore. By 1907, the folklore had evolved, attributing a name to the trapper—Retzler—and to his canine companion—Harper.
Adventurous travelers drawn to this hauntingly beautiful area sought to see the remnants of this story, which included bones and an old flintlock rifle. As visitors ventured into the cave, they dubbed it "Old Man's Cave," captivated by both the narrative and the natural beauty surrounding them.
As time marched on into the 1960s, the name Retzler faded into obscurity, replaced by the fictitious name of Richard Roe, a curious twist in the tale’s evolution.
Today, Old Man's Cave remains a highlight of Hocking Hills State Park, one of its seven stunning hiking trail areas. Many consider it the most popular path, inviting hikers to explore its breathtaking scenery and immerse themselves in the rich tapestry of history and legend that fills the air.